Picture of author.

Susan Palwick

Author of The Necessary Beggar

32+ Works 918 Members 46 Reviews 3 Favorited

About the Author

Image credit: Alec Ausbrooks

Works by Susan Palwick

The Necessary Beggar (2005) 313 copies, 11 reviews
Flying in Place (1992) 170 copies, 9 reviews
Shelter (2007) 148 copies, 5 reviews
The Fate of Mice (2007) 116 copies, 7 reviews
Mending the Moon (2013) 56 copies, 2 reviews
All Worlds are Real: Short Fictions (2019) 23 copies, 2 reviews
Recoveries (2018) 12 copies, 2 reviews
The Fate of Mice (2007) 12 copies, 1 review
Homecoming: A Tor.Com Original (2013) 10 copies, 1 review
Forever Magazine Issue 1 (2015) — Contributor — 8 copies, 1 review
Ever After {short story} (1987) 7 copies, 1 review
The Long View {short story} (2022) 4 copies, 2 reviews

Associated Works

Ruby Slippers, Golden Tears (1995) — Contributor — 959 copies, 12 reviews
The Living Dead (2008) — Contributor — 930 copies, 21 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Eighteenth Annual Collection (2001) — Contributor — 481 copies, 2 reviews
The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: First Annual Collection (1986) — Contributor — 319 copies, 6 reviews
Sisters of the Revolution: A Feminist Speculative Fiction Anthology (2015) — Contributor — 306 copies, 8 reviews
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2015 (2015) — Contributor — 272 copies, 9 reviews
The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fifteenth Annual Collection (2002) — Contributor — 268 copies, 4 reviews
The Armless Maiden: And Other Tales for Childhood's Survivors (1995) — Contributor — 248 copies, 4 reviews
The Urban Fantasy Anthology (2011) — Contributor — 203 copies, 3 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Fifth Annual Collection (1988) — Author — 200 copies, 2 reviews
Future on Fire (1991) — Contributor — 191 copies, 5 reviews
The Year's Best Science Fiction: Thirty-Second Annual Collection (2015) — Contributor — 176 copies, 7 reviews
The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy of the Year Volume Two (2008) — Contributor — 167 copies, 4 reviews
Running with the Pack (2010) — Contributor — 151 copies, 6 reviews
Lightspeed: Year One (2011) — Contributor — 140 copies, 1 review
Starlight 1 (1996) — Contributor — 133 copies, 2 reviews
The Horns of Elfland (1997) — Contributor — 126 copies, 2 reviews
Not of Woman Born (1999) — Contributor — 124 copies, 2 reviews
Starlight 3 (2001) — Contributor — 106 copies
Science Fiction: The Best of the Year, 2006 Edition (2006) — Contributor — 98 copies, 3 reviews
The Best of Pulphouse: The Hardback Magazine (1991) — Contributor — 92 copies
New Magics (2004) — Contributor — 91 copies, 3 reviews
The Best American Science Fiction and Fantasy 2023 (2023) — Contributor — 82 copies, 3 reviews
Isaac Asimov's Vampires (1996) — Contributor — 72 copies, 1 review
Virtuous Vampires (1996) — Contributor — 54 copies
The Year's Best Fantasy Stories: 14 (1988) — Contributor — 51 copies
Xanadu 3 (1995) — Contributor — 40 copies, 2 reviews
Walls of Fear (1990) — Contributor — 34 copies
Spirits of Christmas (1989) — Contributor — 31 copies
The Alchemy of Stars: Rhysling Award Winners Showcase (2005) — Contributor — 29 copies
Great Tales of Madness and the Macabre (1990) — Contributor — 25 copies, 2 reviews
Clarkesworld: Year Eight (2016) — Contributor — 18 copies
Clarkesworld: Issue 096 (September 2014) (2014) — Contributor, some editions — 14 copies, 2 reviews
Asimov's Science Fiction: Vol. 29, No. 1 [January 2005] (2005) — Contributor — 13 copies
Asimov's Science Fiction: Vol. 24, No. 5 [May 2000] (2000) — Contributor — 11 copies, 2 reviews
Clarkesworld: Issue 091 (April 2014) (2014) — Contributor — 11 copies, 1 review
Asimov's Science Fiction: Vol. 38, No. 9 [September 2014] (2014) — Contributor — 10 copies, 1 review
Narrative Power: Encounters, Celebrations, Struggles (2010) — Contributor — 10 copies, 1 review
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 8 • January 2011 (2011) — Contributor — 7 copies
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 83 • April 2017 (2017) — Contributor — 7 copies, 1 review
Clarkesworld: Issue 158 (November 2019) (2019) — Interviewed — 4 copies, 1 review
Tor.com Short Fiction March/April 2022 — Contributor — 4 copies
Ghosttide: Tales of Horror, Dark Fantasy, Suspense (1992) — Contributor — 4 copies
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 87 • August 2017 (2017) — Contributor — 3 copies
Lightspeed Magazine, Issue 145 (June 2022) (2022) — Contributor — 3 copies, 1 review
The Year's Best Fantasy, Volume Two (2023) — Contributor — 3 copies
Already Among Us (2012) — Contributor — 2 copies

Tagged

anthology (1,052) collection (63) ebook (123) fairy tale (20) fairy tale retelling (21) fairy tales (184) fantasy (832) feminism (32) fiction (731) goodreads (23) hardcover (22) horror (354) Kindle (53) magazine (42) novel (20) own (36) owned (25) paperback (48) poetry (28) read (62) retelling (25) science fiction (715) Science Fiction/Fantasy (28) sf (276) sff (117) short fiction (95) short stories (740) short story (38) short story collections (21) signed (23) speculative fiction (86) stories (34) to-read (535) trade paperback (20) unread (111) urban fantasy (34) vampires (32) wishlist (23) year's best (34) zombies (116)

Common Knowledge

Members

Reviews

'Shelter' was first published in 2007 and I have no memory of how it ended up on my to-read list. I bought a second-hand copy off eBay, then ignored it for a while as it smelled a bit odd. There is no mention in the blurb of a plague, so I was deeply disconcerted that the novel begins with a scene of an 8 year old girl quarantined in hospital suffering from a pandemic virus named, I shit you not, CV. This virus also spreads in the air and causes a serious post-viral syndrome in many who recover from it. None of that is particularly sibylline except the name CV, I guess. The opening chapter was a flashback and thankfully the vast majority of the novel plays out long after the pandemic ended. I am in no mood for pandemic sci-fi right now, thanks. 'Shelter' earned its alternate history tag with these two paragraphs from page 112, which left me gobsmacked:

Meredith survived, as most people who weathered the virus did, because her family was wealthy enough to afford round-the-clock, individual medical care, teams of doctors to track the progress of CV in her system and treat its various manifestations as quickly as possible. The pandemic was relatively limited in the United States, thanks largely to Preston's swift recognition of the dire nature of his illness. Because he had called the Bio-containment Unit as soon as he had, everyone who had been on the company jet back from Africa, and all of their contacts since landing, were promptly isolated, at MacroCorp's expense. A few dozen people died - the pilot and several flight attendants, and various people they'd kissed, spoken to, or visited since landing - but at least so far, Preston's foresight seemed to have prevented a major outbreak in the US.

From the television news, when she was well enough to tell her father to vanish from the screen so that she could watch it, Meredith learned of the fate of thousands of Preston's African employees, one of whom had evidently infected him during a plant tour. Without access to isolation, they didn't survive. The virus spread so easily, especially in countries where people still spoke to each other most often in person, rather than by phone or the Net. Neither did vast numbers of their relatives and friends. The ill soon swelled into the tens of thousands, a complex web of human relationships ensuring that by the time the epidemic ended, much of Africa and large pockets of Asia and South America, already ravaged by HIV, would be further decimated.


There is so much in there that now seems horribly unrealistic. (Quite apart from the lazy treatment of Africa like a country rather than a continent. Where did this flight take off from, Africa Airport?) Imagine a super-rich American businessman reporting his own illness then paying for his employees to quarantine! Imagine the US authorities tracing all their contacts and isolating them! Imagine dozens dying of a pandemic virus in the US rather than 439,830 as of 3rd February 2021!

I am not blaming Susan Palwick for failing to predict in 2007 that incompetent neo-nationalist demogogues would let many thousands more people die in the US and UK than countries with ostensibly much weaker health systems. I just assumed this was a completely alternate universe, in which climate change was mostly under control and Gaia worship a normal part of American culture. It evidently wasn't intended as a utopia, though. Three major themes are mental illness, personhood, and medical surveillance. The structure of the book reminded me somewhat of The Untamed, as it initially plunges you straight into dramatic events without explaining who anyone is - a major character dies on page 26. There follows the main substance of the book, consisting of two massive flashbacks in which each protagonist more or less recounts their life to date.

The two protagonists, Meredith and Roberta, have very different backgrounds yet their lives are significantly intertwined. Both experience tragedy, moral dilemmas, and mental illness. However Meredith is rich, white, and privileged while Roberta is not, which makes their experiences very different. Meredith struggles to conceal her problems from the media, but remains largely in control of how she is treated. Roberta is diagnosed with 'excessive altruism', considered a mental illness, and puts up with intrusive surveillance in order to avoid having her brain wiped. One result of the CV pandemic is a modified form of the virus can be used to wipe people's memories, personality, and knowledge. It is widely used as a punishment for criminals and a treatment for mental illness, including in children. In parallel, there is a debate about whether AIs are people and entitled to the rights of a person. In the middle of this are the few able to save their memories in the cloud and exist as uploaded personalities after death. I appreciated the thoughtful way these issues were examined, including sadly realistic details like people ending up homeless post-brainwipe.

'Shelter' is an interesting examination of privilege and inequality, via a small cast of characters whose lives are recounted in great detail. I think it could have been a little shorter. The sequences in a nursery school were very tense but somewhat repetitive, for instance. It reads as meandering and considered sci-fi with horror overtones, that slowly builds up detailed characterisation of the flawed yet sympathetic protagonists. The two twists at the end were a little too neat and one was easy to predict from the start. The conclusion wasn't really as important as the journey there, however. 'Shelter' wanders through domestic settings in an unusual alternate universe, conveying thoughtful insights about how we treat AI and each other via interpersonal drama.
… (more)
 
Flagged
annarchism | 4 other reviews | Aug 4, 2024 |
 
Flagged
greer.d | 1 other review | Jul 30, 2024 |
This was beautifully written. A lovely story, about refugees from another dimension who make a life for themselves in the United States. That setting makes it interesting, but mostly the story is about the characters, and about both family and chosen families.
I thought the death that started the whole thing off was quite silly, and didn't make any sense when you learn what actually happened. And the ending seemed a bit quick to me. But neither one of these things detracted from the sweetness of this book.… (more)
 
Flagged
zjakkelien | 10 other reviews | Jan 2, 2024 |
Set not too far in the future, this novel is an immigration story with a difference. A family has been ousted from Lemabantunk, a world where the punishment for murder includes the entire extended family of the perpetrator. Placed behind wire in an interment camp, the family members cope in different ways, reminding us how varied outsiders' responses can be. Unable to divulge their origins and need for asylum, their reactions vary from suicide to anger to acceptance. In Lemabantunk the society is based on the concept of necessary beggars, who offer the opportunity to display generosity and redemption, but the newcomers to earth must find new paths to acceptance.… (more)
 
Flagged
sleahey | 10 other reviews | Apr 8, 2023 |

Lists

Awards

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Statistics

Works
32
Also by
55
Members
918
Popularity
#27,946
Rating
3.8
Reviews
46
ISBNs
27
Languages
1
Favorited
3

Charts & Graphs